A few years ago, I worked in at our school districts online
elementary school. I was directly out of
my student teaching and had spent time in the online environment earning my
teacher’s license. So there was some familiarity
with the online learning environment, but not enough to call myself an
expert.
In the middle of the school year, our principal wanted some of the
staff members to try incorporating video instruction into our daily lessons
online. I wanted to try doing this to
bring more engagement to the lessons for my students online. Being one of the only teachers trying to do
this, it was rather frustrating to have little support trying to record myself
to have a face to go along with each lesson.
My principal suggested that I start with just one grade level lesson and
try moving forward from there. But being
the perfectionist that I am, I wanted to try and do it for two grade
levels. At first, I spent a lot of time
trying to figure out how I was going to use the video instruction. I decided to use it for my discussions on
novels the students were reading. I
wanted to create questions for each novel and then put them in a video asking
the students the discussion questions for that week. At first, I was able to record the video, but
figuring out how to embed it into the website so the video was view-able was
bleeding my most valuable resource, time.
I was spending too much time on this project that it was biting into my
time to create the other lessons for the other grade levels. About two weeks in, I finally was able to get
two videos up for 3rd and 4th grade literacy circles. After putting the videos up, I realized that
the videos weren’t very effective because it was just me asking a question to
the students and not actually engaging in a conversation. I quickly was demoralized by my failure and
decided to scrap the project. My principal supported my decision to stop making
the videos but also tried to convince me to use the video in a different way in
my instruction. But I was just too
deflated by my failure to even consider moving in a different direction. This is one of my biggest regrets as a
teacher to this day. Giving up on that
project was the easy thing to do. I chose
to take the easy road instead of learning from my mistakes and moving
forward.
Upon reflection, I can now see that I was the cause of the scope
creep for my own project. Thinking that
I could learn how to create the video, change the format, embed into the
website and make it engaging for the students in two grade levels instead of
one was just too much work. I can now
see the importance of taking baby steps while moving through a new teaching
technique. Taking small steps at the
beginning can help you take much bigger steps later on in the future. This failure in the past has helped me be
successful with other projects as a teacher today. Learning from that mistake has helped me be a
successful teacher.
Hi Andrew,
ReplyDeleteI hear your pain. Since I have worked in the film/video industry for many years, I can totally understand why video seems easy at first, but then becomes more complicated as you dig deeper into it, not to mention the technical challenges with trial and error. One of my daily struggles is explaining the process of creating videos and the time involved and how it’s not just a couple of steps and flipping a switch. Video projects can be projects where Project Management could potentially be a valuable asset. During this course I can see a lot of parallels between what I do in video production and project management. Although by your comments, you regret it, I believe that it’s a challenge especially if you do not have support. One thing that our text mentions about scope creep “ The best approach is to set up a well-controlled formal process whereby changes can be introduced and accomplished with as little distress as possible“ (Portney, Mantel, Meredith, Shafer, Sutton & Kramer, 2008, pg 346). Take little steps and see what works and add as you go. It works that way with every project I have worked on in video, the next project is always better and has more impact than the one before.
References:
Portny, S. E., Mantel, S. J., Meredith, J. R., Shafer, S. M., Sutton, M. M., & Kramer, B. E. (2008). Project management: Planning, scheduling, and controlling projects. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.